I make no apologies as a fan of my particular teams, despite my ability to separate myself as an academic with my subject of inquiry. But even for a quantitative researcher such as myself, it is sometimes difficult to separate my fandom from my analysis.
Which leads me to Wednesday’s announcement of Indianapolis Colts quarterback Phillip Rivers’ retirement.
I was not one of the skeptical fans and media pundits who wondered aloud if Rivers had much left in the tank. There were some who questioned if the Colts made a “risky move” in going after Old Man Rivers instead of a younger more athletic Cam Newton, who ended up in New England. Rivers only signed a one-year deal at a rather reasonable rate, and considering the struggles of the team under Jacoby Brissett after the “stunning” retirement of Andrew Luck, the move made financial sense and would clearly be an improvement at the position.
And while no one was fooling themselves thinking the Rivers signing was anything other than a temporary stopgap delaying the inevitable, any improvement upon Brissett’s numbers would have been a boon to the 2020-2021 season’s prospects.
Which is exactly what Rivers brought to the Colts. Yes, he had an immediate impact on the offense, throwing for 4,169 yards, 24 touchdowns and 11 interceptions completing 68% of his passes. Yes, he got better as the season went along, leading the Horseshoe to an 11-5 record and nearly winning the division.
But in my observation, he made the team better beyond his term, something not a lot of aging quarterbacks are apt to do with a new team after a lengthy run with their original team. Psst… I’m looking at you Brett Favre with MInnesota and Donovan McNabb with Washington.
Instead, Rivers has set the Colts on a solid path moving forward. Sure, they will miss his offensive production, but greatly improved a deficit receiving corps by bringing along wideouts such as Michael Pittman, Jr. and Zach Pascal, both of whom look like future stars at the position. He helped improve a running game that suffered with the loss of starting RB Marlon Mack, but rebounded quickly with possible offensive rookie of the year Jonathan Taylor and a burgeoning Nyheim Hines. This team will continue to be an improving offensive power even without Rivers behind center.
But what I found most disappointing was the lack of fanfare for River’s announcement. Oddly timed with Inauguration Day, it seems as if Uncle Phil attempted to avoid the fanfare of the announcement, though he’s never been one to toot his own horn. While a prolific trash-talker (sans curse words, natch), you never heard Rivers tout himself as an all-time great, never heard him complain about a lack of respect or renown, and never attempted to be the center of attention at the expense of teammates. By all measures, he was a lockerroom leader and genuine good guy and teammate.
Philip Rivers is a sure-fire Hall of Famer, and I for one will miss his presence in the game.